Commercial Leasing in Alexandria VA: Turning Lemons Into Lemonade

Lemons Into Lemonade: How a Failed Lease Led Us Back to Our First Choice in Old Town Alexandria

I recently worked with a client to launch a new business in his search in Old Town
Alexandria. His creative agency was launching a new concept: a retail shopping
establishment with an invitation-based membership program. He wanted something with
a funky, speakeasy vibe.

This was not your typical site selection.  Explaining to landlords that a tenant’s business model is built on private membership
and experiential retail comes with its own set of challenges. Fortunately, my client had a
pitch deck that told the story. Finding space that actually fits the look and feel of the
concept was a challenge entirely. Still, we found a handful of options that checked the
boxes.

The First Choice That Wasn’t Available
One of those properties was a three-story building that could potentially be leased to
three separate tenants. When we first toured it, though, the owner was focused on
selling. Leasing a single floor was possible in theory, but it wasn’t likely to happen.
Realistically, we could lease all three floors or buy the building.
Neither made sense for my client, so we put that property on ice and turned our
attention to another space with its own unique character that fit the concept.

The Deal That Went Quiet
After several site visits with my client and his contractors, the team agreed the space
worked, and we moved into negotiations. We set up an onsite, face-to-face meeting
between the landlord and my client. Everyone left comfortable with each other, and we
agreed on the terms of the LOI. That’s where the train jumped the track. Nothing. Radio silence from ownership. The
lease never came and the landlord stopped communications.
There was no rhyme or reason to it, other than that our deal simply wasn’t a priority for
the landlord. I know the guy’s busy, but give me a break. We’re trying to do some
business here. As painful as it was, we had to move on. All the time we’d invested in
that space turned out to be a big fat lemon!

Back to the Market
The clock was ticking, and we were tired of waiting, so back to the market we went. My
client was understandably frustrated, and nothing new had come up that made sense to
pursue. So I reached back out to the broker on our original first choice, the three-story building
that had only been available for sale. As it turned out, the sale had fallen through. That opened the door to a lease. Even
better, the listing broker had a tenant who wanted the first floor and lower level, and my
client wanted the second floor.

There was a catch. The landlord would only lease the building to multiple tenants if he
had tenants in place, with leases in hand, for each floor. And we had a small window to
get both deals negotiated and approved before the landlord started entertaining another
buyer’s purchase offer.

Getting It Done
Long story short, the stars aligned. We got both tenants’ deals negotiated and both
leases signed by each tenant, so the landlord had both leases sitting on his desk, ready
to execute together. That was the only way these deals were getting done.
In the end, my client was happy with his lease terms and even happier that we secured
the building he wanted in the first place. We turned those lemons into lemonade.

What Tenants Can Take From This
Every deal has its own twists, but a few lessons from this one apply to almost any
commercial real estate search requirement.

1. An LOI is not a lease. A signed LOI means everyone agrees on the big terms. It
doesn’t mean the landlord is committed to getting a deal done. Until a lease is executed,
keep your options alive and keep the pressure on the timeline. It’s reasonable to ask for
a target date for the first lease draft when the LOI is signed.
2. “Not available” is a snapshot, not a final answer. Buildings that are for sale today
can be for lease tomorrow. Sales fall through, ownership priorities change, and other
tenants come and go. The property you passed on six months ago may be the right
answer now.
3. Relationships with listing brokers matter. The deal only came together because
we had a good relationship with the listing broker, and that broker was willing to work
with us to put two tenants together in one building. A tenant rep who is known and
respected in the market can open doors that a cold inquiry can’t.
4. Be willing to get creative on structure. The landlord wasn’t going to split the
building for one tenant. Two tenants, with coordinated leases signed and delivered
together, changed his math. When a space doesn’t work the way it’s being marketed,
ask what it would take to make it work.

5. Unusual concepts need someone to tell the story. Landlords like to understand
what they’re getting. If your business model is new or doesn’t fit a standard box, how it’s
presented to ownership can make the difference between a tour and a signed lease.

The Bottom Line
Deals stall, landlords go quiet, and first choices get taken off the table. But that doesn’t
have to be the end of the story. Staying persistent, always having a second & third
option, staying in touch with the market, and being ready to pivot when a window opens
is how you end up in the space you want.

If you’re searching for space in Northern Virginia, or you’re stuck on a deal that isn’t
moving, let’s talk.
Ryan Cramsey, Director of Office Leasing, 703.639.7626, [email protected]